A board treasurer receives the audit communications and sees the phrase nonprofit control deficiency. The immediate question is usually not technical: Does this mean something was mishandled? The answer depends on the nature, scope, and potential consequence of the condition. A control deficiency is not automatically evidence of fraud, inaccurate financial statements, or grant noncompliance. It is, however, a signal that the organization’s existing processes may not prevent or detect an error promptly enough.
For nonprofit leaders, that distinction matters. A well-run organization can have a control deficiency because of limited staffing, a newly implemented financial system, rapid program growth, turnover in the finance function, or controls that have not kept pace with increasingly complex funding requirements. The responsible response is neither to minimize the finding nor to overreact. It is to understand the risk clearly, assign ownership, and document a corrective path that the board and management can monitor.
What Is a Nonprofit Control Deficiency?
Internal control is the system of policies, approvals, reconciliations, oversight, and information flow that supports reliable financial reporting, protects assets, and promotes compliance. In a nonprofit setting, controls also help demonstrate that restricted funds, government awards, donor contributions, and program expenditures are handled according to their intended purpose.
A control deficiency exists when the design or operation of a control does not allow management or employees, in the normal course of performing their duties, to prevent or detect misstatements on a timely basis. The issue may involve a missing control, such as the lack of an independent bank reconciliation review. It may also involve a control that exists on paper but is not consistently performed or documented.
Auditors evaluate identified deficiencies in the context of the financial statements and, when applicable, compliance requirements. They communicate certain matters to those charged with governance because the board has a direct stewardship responsibility. The terminology can be technical, but the governing question is practical: What could go wrong, how likely is it, and would the organization identify the problem before it causes harm?
Deficiency, Significant Deficiency, and Material Weakness
Not every control issue carries the same weight. Auditing standards distinguish among a control deficiency, a significant deficiency, and a material weakness.
A control deficiency may be relatively limited in scope or risk. For example, a supervisor may review credit-card activity but fail to evidence that review with a signature, date, or electronic approval. The activity may still be monitored, but the organization cannot readily demonstrate that the control occurred.
A significant deficiency is important enough to merit the attention of those charged with governance. It may not rise to the level of a material weakness, but it presents a meaningful risk that financial reporting errors or compliance failures could occur without timely detection.
A material weakness is more serious. It indicates a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement of the financial statements will not be prevented or detected and corrected promptly. For organizations subject to a Single Audit or governmental audit requirements, the consequences may extend beyond financial reporting. A material weakness in internal control over compliance can affect the organization’s audit reporting, grantor relationships, and future monitoring obligations.
The classification is based on professional judgment. A small organization with limited personnel will not be evaluated by the same operational model as a large institution with a full accounting department. Yet size does not eliminate the need for compensating controls and active governance.
Where Control Deficiencies Commonly Arise
Many nonprofit control deficiencies arise in routine processes, not extraordinary events. The risk often increases when one trusted employee handles too many stages of a transaction, when reviews are informal, or when documentation is scattered across email, paper files, and multiple software platforms.
Common areas include:
- Bank reconciliations that are prepared late, lack independent review, or contain old unexplained reconciling items.
- Cash disbursements processed without documented approval, adequate invoice support, or review of vendor changes.
- Revenue and receivables procedures that do not reconcile donor databases, billing systems, grant drawdowns, and the general ledger.
- Payroll controls that lack independent review of new hires, wage rates, timesheets, leave balances, or payroll-change reports.
- Grant compliance procedures that do not consistently document eligibility, allowable costs, procurement, subrecipient monitoring, or reporting deadlines.
- Journal entries, especially manual entries, that are posted without preparer support and independent approval.
In a Uniform Guidance environment, the organization should assess controls against the compliance requirements of each major federal program. A finance department may have strong general ledger procedures while still having weaknesses in program-level documentation, time-and-effort support, procurement files, or subrecipient oversight. Compliance controls must be designed around the actual award terms and applicable federal requirements, not assumed to exist because the accounting records are accurate.
Why Boards Should Treat Findings as Governance Information
An audit finding should not be viewed solely as a finance department problem. Management operates controls, but the board and audit committee provide oversight. Their role is to ask whether the organization understands the condition, whether the proposed corrective action addresses the root cause, and whether progress is being verified.
This is especially relevant when the same issue appears year after year. A recurring deficiency can suggest that prior remediation was too narrow, insufficiently resourced, or never fully embedded into the organization’s normal workflow. A policy adopted after the audit is not, by itself, a corrected control. The organization must show that the policy is being followed, that evidence of performance is retained, and that exceptions are escalated.
Boards should also resist an unproductive focus on the wording of the finding alone. Whether an issue is labeled a significant deficiency or a material weakness is consequential, but the more valuable discussion concerns exposure and accountability. Could restricted revenue be recorded incorrectly? Could unallowable grant costs be charged without detection? Could an unauthorized disbursement occur? Could the organization submit a report that management has not adequately reviewed?
Those questions turn the audit communication into the clearest picture your board will ever get of how financial risk moves through the organization.
A Practical Response to a Control Deficiency
Management’s corrective action plan should be specific enough to be tested. Broad statements such as “management will be more careful” do not establish accountability or reduce risk. A credible plan identifies the affected process, the root cause, the revised control activity, the responsible individual, the implementation date, and the evidence that will demonstrate performance.
Start by determining whether the deficiency is one of design or operation. If there is no independent review of bank reconciliations, the control may need to be designed and assigned. If a review is required but occurred inconsistently, the design may be adequate while execution and documentation need attention. The distinction affects the remedy.
Next, consider whether segregation of duties is feasible. Smaller nonprofits often cannot separate custody, recording, authorization, and reconciliation among several employees. In that circumstance, compensating controls become essential. Examples include a finance committee member reviewing bank reconciliations, an executive director approving detailed disbursement reports, or a board treasurer reviewing payroll changes and significant journal entries. These reviewers must receive timely, meaningful information and retain evidence of their review.
Technology can support remediation, but it does not replace management judgment. Accounting systems may provide approval workflows, user-access reports, audit trails, and automated exception reports. Those tools are useful only when access rights are reviewed, approvals are meaningful, and exceptions are investigated. Automating a weak process can make a weak process move faster.
Finally, establish a follow-up cadence. Management should report progress to the audit committee or board, particularly for significant deficiencies, material weaknesses, and grant-related findings. The board should know not only whether a procedure has been implemented, but whether it has operated long enough to demonstrate consistency.
Documentation Is Part of the Control
Nonprofits sometimes perform sound oversight but cannot prove it. A controller may discuss a reconciliation with the CFO, or a board officer may review financial reports before a meeting, without leaving a record of questions, approvals, or follow-up. From an audit and governance perspective, undocumented review is difficult to distinguish from no review at all.
Documentation need not be burdensome. A dated electronic approval, checklist, meeting minute, reconciliation sign-off, or retained review memorandum may be sufficient, depending on the process. The goal is to create clear evidence that the right person reviewed the right information at the right time and addressed exceptions.
This discipline is particularly valuable when personnel change. Controls that depend entirely on one individual’s memory or informal routines are fragile. Written procedures, defined responsibilities, and retained evidence allow the organization to sustain financial discipline through turnover, growth, and changing funding demands.
A control deficiency is best addressed before it becomes a reporting problem, questioned cost, or governance crisis. When management and the board approach the issue with precision rather than defensiveness, the corrective process can strengthen not only audit results, but the organization’s capacity to safeguard the resources entrusted to its mission.
This article is general information, not accounting, audit, or tax advice, and it does not create a client relationship. Thresholds and filing requirements change. Confirm anything you intend to rely on against the current rules or speak with us directly.
Talk to an auditor
Goldenthal & Suss performs nonprofit audits, single audits, and Yellow Book government engagements from offices in Staten Island, New York City and Freehold, NJ.
Request a Proposal